Isabel,
For me this is an image that you can 'play' with in a number of different ways but only 'you' will be able to decide which one fits your mood at the time.
Looking at both your version and Andre's I get the feeling that the weathers brightening up but only you will know if that was the case and the saturated greens seem to suggest that to me as well.
Here's a couple of other alternatives, certainly not saying they are better in any way and I attempted to use different gradients in each to focus more on the puddle.
You took on a good challenge with a great result.
Grahame