Evolution

[Skitalez]

Hello everyone! I wish to hear your opinion. It is So much time with these photo that I can not draw the conclusion. Probably some mistakes and remark??
1.


2.


In my opinion, in the second photo there is some spot of colors (((
ThanX Everyone!

[dje]

Hi Yegor

For me, it's the right hand version of image 1 (although they are both fine) and the left hand version of image 2. The colour in the right hand version of image 2 is too much for me

Cheers Dave

[Skitalez]

Certainly, this the same the photo. 2 shots and 2 versions PP.)))) You are observant)))) I agree! I shall lower a saturation

[GrahamH]

Definitely number 2. (The water in 1 detracts, use the water from 2 in both then 1 will work for me a lot more).
I love the sky in 4 but the water detracts mightily. Boost the contrast in the sky in 3 and it would work much better for me.

Generally I love the sky in both compositions and like the water less, so I would crop significantly.
Graham

[Donald]

Yegor

I would agree with Dave's assessment. The reason for doing so is that I think you have got more texture and subtlety of tone into the two that Dave and I prefer. In particular, I think there is a great difference in the texture in the first image, with the right hand image being of much better quality.

[Skitalez]

Thank you all! I had the same doubts. I used 2 ways. Anyhow, the way 1 works better. (a photo 1а and 2а originals. It is only a little ACR)