Experience with Nik Dfin

[kdoc856]

Hey all,

I've been experimenting with Nik Dfin 2 (Nik's noise reduction software). In spite of seeing many good reviews, and watching tutorials and webinars, I am not happy with the results. Yes, it reduces a lot of noise, but I feel I've lost too much definition that I cant seem to get back when I sharpen. I've tried both the automatic mode and manual, and it always works out about the same. Is it me, the program, or lack of enough experience (not sure if experience really matters with this). Any thoughts or experience appreciated.

Thanks,

Kevin

[Shadowman]

Hey all,

I've been experimenting with Nik Dfin 2 (Nik's noise reduction software). In spite of seeing many good reviews, and watching tutorials and webinars, I am not happy with the results. Yes, it reduces a lot of noise, but I feel I've lost too much definition that I cant seem to get back when I sharpen. I've tried both the automatic mode and manual, and it always works out about the same. Is it me, the program, or lack of enough experience (not sure if experience really matters with this). Any thoughts or experience appreciated.

Thanks,

Kevin

Not familiar with the software but does it give you the option to make multiple layers gradually reducing noise so that the layers can be blended together?

[kdoc856]

Hey, John

Dont think so. It's pretty heavily automated, and at most gives one the ability to set control points in differrent areas of the image so the sharpening can be modified according to region. But the noise always seems to e exchanged for a slight smearing effect and I cant tell which is worse

Thanks,

Kevin

[Shadowman]

Hey, John

Dont think so. It's pretty heavily automated, and at most gives one the ability to set control points in differrent areas of the image so the sharpening can be modified according to region. But the noise always seems to e exchanged for a slight smearing effect and I cant tell which is worse

Thanks,

Kevin

Have you viewed the video on the website? The example shown was on an image with minimal shadows but it looks user friendly.

[kdoc856]

John,

Sure did. No doubt it's user friendly. Maybe too much so. I've spent several hours since my initial post running several high ISO shots through Dfin- I'm concluding it's a worthwhile adjustment Sometimes but not consistently so, and my approach may end up being giving it a shot on a trial and error basis till I can discern whether there are some discernible predictors of when it's likely to help. Thanks for the input.

Kevin

[Poaceae]

Kevin, I primarily use Lightroom 3 when I need noise reduction but I do use Nik and am happy with it. Are you using Define 2.0? It is a big improvement over the previous version. Here is a link to an article that might be of help.
http://www.thelightsright.com/files/.../nikdfine2.pdf

[Mark Lawrence]

I find Imagenomic's Noiseware professional does a much better job all around and is more adjustable.