Water Droplet

[Andrew76]

Hello, I have a couple of questions:

1) Do you prefer this image:



OR

2) This image with the water-stained background:



AND

3) Are either of them worth keeping? There sure are a lot of water droplet pictures floating around, but I thought I would try one for fun.

Thanks!!

[JPS]

Andrew,
nice simple answer, No.1 is the keeper for me.
Let's see how the majority vote.

[Bobobird]

Judging from the angle the droplet is on some sort of surface. #1 is defying physics without a surface context. So for me #2 as it is more realistic.

[Kris V]

I vote for # 2.

[Kathy O]

Love #1!!!

[Goldcoastgolfer]

Prefer the simplicity of #1

[epmi314]

#1

[Andrew76]

Thanks for the feedback. As much as I love the 'process' of adding textures to my photos - it never seems to work out for the better. My wife voted #1 last night when she got home from work, so I guess that's the decider!

Thanks again.