Trace
They're all gorgeous pictures of nice times. In terms a more constructive critical appraisal, I'd go to #1 and #2 as very good images in terms of composition, lighting, a story. I think they are lovely images.
#5 tells us about being at the beach, but is not such a well lit or composed image, in my view.
#3 and #4 are good potrait shopts of the dogs, but I think the last one suffers from the fact that you are up high looking down on the dog.
But #1 and #2 are gorgeous.
What kind of dogs are they; I had a sheepdog once that went nuts whenever it went to the beach.![]()
Thanks Donald, appreciate your feedbackAnd yes, I agree with all of what you have said. The first two are my choices as well... and are the ones I am generally more willing to share with non-doggy audiences, though 2 would have much more impact if she'd been looking towards me. The portraits of my oldies (3&4) are treasured simply because they are old now and every photo of them enjoying life suddenly becomes more special. 5 & 6 were just cause I couldn't help myself
Appreciate you taking the time to look and comment!![]()
They are shetland sheepdogs / sheltiesI also have a border collie who would not be happy to know she'd been left out
And yes they all love the beach- we are fortunate it is so close and we can frequent it often; helps us all stay fit and sane.
Very nice shots (I like them all (although 1 and 2 are the best), because I am doggy audience). I also know how difficult it is to photograph them, as they are constantly moving, so great work.
Trace,
I like them all except for #3. The angle and crop produce a kind of floating dog head-and-shoulders with nothing to ground it. Even the OOF tail on the left just seems to cause more confusion for me. The lack of legs or the rest of the dog just doesn't sit well in my head.
However, having said that, I have to disagree with Donald's comment about the last one. I think that (unless all of your shots are from this perspective) this kind of shot gives a sense of a dog's obedience and devotion to its owner. That gaze - especially the one here that is full of affection and happiness - can be very powerful in a dog shot. Especially when it is balanced with many of the shots like you have that are more on his/her level. So I personally like it.
Nice shots of a beautiful dog.
- Bill
Thanks Peter, Glad you enjoyed them!
Bill, thanks for your feedback! And yes, I can see your perspective on number 3... the combination of the angle, the dof, and the half-way between head-shot and full-body didn't produce the most well-balanced portrait. And yes, I do also like the last one for that exact reason, even though I'm aware it breaks the perspective/dog/pet photography "rule"; it does capture a look and a moment that I see on a daily basis and that never fails to get me to smile in return.
Last edited by PhotoByTrace; 3rd August 2011 at 06:45 AM.
Very nice images. It's amazing how dogs will avoid a bath but give them the opportunity to get wet on their own and there's no stopping them.
The second image really tells the story. Great image.![]()
All are neat images but, somehow I like #1 the best!
Great fun shots. Should be more of them - thanks for sharing.