Reflections

[billm]

CC'S apreciated.Is the post processing over done,color look ok?

[Donald]

Bill - I'm not the best person to comment on colour accuracy and I wasn't there to see what it looked like, but it seems overdone to me. The trees don't seem a natural colour, but I may be wrong on that. Also, I don't think the trees are as sharp as they need to be. Did this start as a RAW file and have you done any sharpening in post-processing?

I do like the composition. The closer trees right and left 'book-end' the scene in a very nice way.

[cliffmccartney]

It might be a tad overdone, but I don't think it's that bad. My problem is that it seems to be a bit soft.

[billm]

I think you are both right it is a bit soft and I think in my effort to bring the definition to the clouds I over saturated the whole picture.It did start as raw,I'll have to look how much I sharpening I did. thanks for your comments

[JPS]

Hi Bill,
It does look a bit overdone on my screen too. However, as Donald said you would be the best one to know how it looked when you took the shot.
I must admit I like the composition and the reflection in the water; well done.
I hope you don't mind I tried some small adjustments on your picture, to give another option and give a platform for further discussion.
Thanks for sharing.
John

[billm]

I like what you did john, I think I need a color matched moniter.